top of page

Has Natural Wine Become Mainstream (and Is That a Good Thing)?

If you’d mentioned natural wine at a dinner party 15 years ago, you might have been met with blank stares or polite nods of indifference. Back then, natural wine was the rebellious child of the wine world—a scrappy upstart embraced by a small, passionate following. Fast forward to today, and suddenly you can find natural wine in trendy wine bars, restaurants, and even your neighborhood supermarket. So, the question remains: has natural wine become too mainstream? And more importantly, is that even a bad thing?


Is Natural Wine Still the Rebellious Outsider?


Once upon a time, natural wine was the choice of the few. It was the kind of thing you had to seek out—an under-the-radar experience for those who were “in the know.” Back in the days when it was only the avant-garde sommeliers who stocked their cellars with low-sulfite bottles, and it was hard to find any mention of natural wine outside of niche bars in Paris or Brooklyn.


But in 2024, natural wine has made its way into the mainstream lexicon. Casual wine drinkers, even those who don't know the tannins from the terroir, can now drop the phrase “natural wine” into a conversation with ease. Sure, they might still associate it with healthiness or low sulfites (spoiler: it’s not always that simple), but the fact that people know the term at all speaks volumes about how much the movement has grown.

And therein lies the crux of the debate: is this rise in popularity diluting natural wine’s original ethos? As with any countercultural trend that goes mainstream, there’s always a risk that the movement’s authenticity gets lost. The very elements that made natural wine an alternative choice—its raw, unpolished nature, its rebellion against mass production—now face the threat of becoming a trendy checkbox on a wine list. But does it really matter, as long as people are enjoying the wine?


How Has Natural Wine Changed the Palate of Wine Consumers?


There’s no question that natural wine has influenced the way we drink. Ten or fifteen years ago, the wine world was dominated by bold, high-alcohol wines, often with a heavy oak influence. This was the era of Robert Parker, where big reds with high scores ruled the market. But natural wine came along and flipped that script. With its focus on freshness, low alcohol, and minimal intervention, natural wine introduced many drinkers to a lighter, more playful style of wine.


What’s fascinating is how this shift has impacted even the most commercial corners of the wine industry. Large-scale producers, who traditionally catered to the Parker-influenced palate, are now following the natural wine trend and creating wines that mimic its style. Take M. Chapoutier’s "Rouge Clair" for example. While not a natural wine, it’s a chillable red in a transparent bottle, low in alcohol, and designed to be enjoyed cool—exactly the kind of easygoing wine that natural wine drinkers love.

Or consider Gérard Bertrand’s "Le Chouchou", which proudly touts its low alcohol content (just 11%) and bursts with juicy, vibrant fruit. This wine, much like the natural wines it draws inspiration from, is meant to be served chilled and enjoyed casually, appealing to a younger generation of wine drinkers who prioritize fun and drinkability over prestige.


These examples show how the natural wine movement has nudged even the most commercial producers to rethink their offerings. Consumers, particularly younger generations, now seek wines that are fresh, lively, and low in alcohol—a far cry from the rich, oaky wines that dominated the market just a decade ago. Natural wine has not only changed what’s on our shelves but also redefined what wine can be: less about complexity and structure, and more about drinkability and approachability.


Is Ubiquity Killing the Charm?


It used to be that if you wanted to drink natural wine, you had to find a wine bar that specialized in it. These days, however, you’d be hard-pressed to find a wine bar in a major city that doesn’t offer natural options. From New York to Copenhagen, Paris to Tokyo, natural wine has made its way into the mainstream, often replacing more traditional offerings.


Some say this is a win for the movement. After all, more access means more people can experience and appreciate what natural wine has to offer. But others worry that the movement’s explosion in popularity is diluting its essence. Wine shops that once ignored natural wine are now dedicating entire sections to it. Is that progress, or just another example of the wine world capitalizing on a trend?


Even major players in the wine industry are jumping on the bandwagon. Commercial wine producers are releasing low-sulfite, organic wines aimed at the growing market for natural-inspired options. Yes, these wines are a far cry from the cloudy, unpredictable bottles of yesteryear’s natural wine pioneers. But can we blame them for catering to a wider audience? After all, isn’t it a sign of success when a movement influences big brands?


This begs the question: is the rise of commercialized natural wines, like those by Chapoutier and Bertrand, a good thing? On the one hand, it brings natural wine to a broader audience. On the other, some purists argue that it turns natural wine into just another trend, stripping away its artisanal roots in favor of consumer-friendly mass appeal.


Has Natural Wine Become a Lifestyle Choice?


Natural wine has undoubtedly tapped into a certain identity—an identity that’s more about lifestyle than just wine. Much like organic foods or eco-friendly products, natural wine allows drinkers to make a statement about their values. It’s not just about what’s in the bottle, but what it represents: a movement against over-industrialization, a desire for authenticity, and, for some, even a rejection of the wine establishment’s elitism.


This lifestyle aspect is both a strength and a potential pitfall. On one hand, it democratizes wine. Natural wine has brought in drinkers who might have previously felt excluded from the sometimes intimidating world of traditional wine. The appeal isn’t about appellation or status—it’s about transparency, simplicity, and a little bit of rebellion.


However, there’s always the risk that natural wine becomes more of a cultural accessory than a true appreciation for what’s in the glass. When a product becomes part of a lifestyle trend, there’s always the danger that it gets reduced to its most superficial elements. Is natural wine turning into just another Instagrammable moment?


What About the Underdog Regions?


One of the most exciting aspects of the natural wine movement has been its ability to elevate lesser-known wine regions. In the traditional wine world, places like Bordeaux or Napa Valley tend to dominate the conversation. But natural wine has given space for regions like Georgia, Greece, and Austria to shine. Producers from these areas, often working with indigenous grapes and low intervention techniques, have found a home in the natural wine community.


What’s particularly compelling is how the natural wine world cares less about appellations and more about winemaking philosophy. It doesn’t matter if a wine is from an AOC region or simply labeled as "Vin de France". What matters is how it’s made, which has allowed winemakers from smaller, less renowned regions to break into international markets.


Is Natural Wine Losing Its Funk?


For all the attention natural wine gets, it’s still a relatively small slice of the global wine market. And yet, some winemakers are feeling the pressure to step away from the movement’s original, funky image. Gone are the days when natural wine was synonymous with “wild” or “unpredictable.” Many producers are striving for cleaner, more refined expressions, hoping to shed the stereotype of natural wine as too “out there” for serious wine drinkers.


What’s interesting is that some winemakers who were once known for their radical, funky styles have gradually shifted toward a more polished approach. These producers, who once embraced cloudy, unfiltered, and unpredictable wines, are now creating bottles that appeal to traditional wine lovers. The wines are still made with minimal intervention, but they’re cleaner, more stable, and less likely to shock the palate.


Is this change a sign of the movement maturing, or is it a sign of natural winemakers themselves growing older—and perhaps more conservative? As some of the pioneers of the natural wine scene settle into their careers, it’s possible that they’re adapting to broader market demands, becoming more “mainstream” in their styles. The rough edges have been smoothed, the funk toned down, and the wines made more accessible to a wider audience.


Whether this shift represents a loss of authenticity or simply an evolution of the craft is up for debate. On one hand, it could be seen as a natural progression, a way to bring more people into the fold. On the other hand, some purists might argue that in striving for mainstream appeal, these winemakers are losing the rebellious spirit that once defined them.


So, Has Natural Wine Become Too Mainstream?


The conclusion is yet to be determined. On one hand, natural wine has started seeking more formalized standards, like Vin Méthode Nature or other natural winemaker associations, which aim to preserve the integrity and philosophy of the movement. These efforts reflect a desire to set clear boundaries around what natural wine truly is, safeguarding it from becoming just another label or marketing trend.


On the other hand, despite its visibility and cultural influence, natural wine still represents a small fraction of the global wine market. Its share of overall wine sales remains relatively modest, indicating that while natural wine may be gaining ground, it hasn’t overtaken the mainstream entirely.


What we do know for sure is that natural wine is no fleeting fad. It has already made a significant and lasting impact on how wine is produced, consumed, and talked about. Whether it continues to grow into something larger or settles into a permanent niche remains to be seen. But one thing is certain: natural wine has changed the conversation, and it’s here to stay.

コメント


bottom of page